Mustang Boards

Mustang Boards (/)
-   General Tech Forum (https://mustangboards.com/general-tech-forum/)
-   -   short shifter question (https://mustangboards.com/general-tech-forum/37559-short-shifter-question.html)

Tape 08-28-2009 08:25 AM


Originally Posted by Steeda21 (Post 426131)
anyone know if i can attach any arm/handle to the pro 5.0? It is kinda short, but its not any issue i just want a longer one maybe.

LOL, you say I don't know anything but I know the answer to that question

wildride02gt 08-28-2009 02:09 PM


Originally Posted by Steeda21 (Post 426131)
anyone know if i can attach any arm/handle to the pro 5.0? It is kinda short, but its not any issue i just want a longer one maybe.

The Pro 5.0 will work with just about any handle designed for the stock-style shifter.

Steeda21 08-28-2009 10:08 PM


Originally Posted by Tape (Post 426165)
go fk yourself asshat! I don't know all but I know alot! "Don't forget we are all on the same team here.
LOL same team, do you call your team-mates douchebag:rolleyes:
yeah, dont waste your time because your will find out your wrong!

hhaha this is funny...not even going to respond to that

Steeda21 08-28-2009 10:09 PM


Originally Posted by Tape (Post 426166)
LOL, you say I don't know anything but I know the answer to that question

didn't say you dont know anyhting i said i thought you were wrong about the short shifter.

I didnt say i knew all

Deathdiesel 08-28-2009 10:54 PM

:hahaha: I see an argument? *Grabs popcorn*

badassGT 08-30-2009 06:39 AM

wow, anyway now what I need to know is is it hard to install a short sifter? Will I need to drop the trans, or can you do it from the inside of the car. After removing the console.

wildride02gt 08-30-2009 08:23 AM

work is done from inside the car, NO tranny removal. Its really too easy. took me about 30 mins, while drinking a beer and BS'n with a buddy.

Tape 08-30-2009 08:55 AM


Originally Posted by Deathdiesel (Post 426316)
:hahaha: I see an argument? *Grabs popcorn*

nope, no argument, no sense in arguing, we just don't agree with each other so you can trash your popcorn:)

TUFF 4.6 09-10-2009 06:46 AM

Im not trying to stir shit, this was copied and pasted from the Hurst web site. This is the shifter for the 3650 trans.

http://www.hurst-shifters.com/images...mon/spacer.gifBILLET/PLUS SHIFTERhttp://www.hurst-shifters.com/images...mon/spacer.gifhttp://www.hurst-shifters.com/images...mon/spacer.gifHurst Billet/Plus Shifters incorporate a high ratio pivot mechanism for reduced shifter throw and are sturdily constructed for a more positive precise feel when shifting. Self centering alignment improves 2nd to 3rd up-shift gear changes to reduce the chance of “missed shifts”. Patented adjustable bias spring loads on most models allow stick tension to be tailored to drivers preference.
Dedicated applications assure a custom fit and eliminate any vehicle modifications for ease of installation.

engineman312 09-10-2009 11:07 AM


Originally Posted by badassGT (Post 426561)
wow, anyway now what I need to know is is it hard to install a short sifter? Will I need to drop the trans, or can you do it from the inside of the car. After removing the console.

i did mine in about an hour, with two different sized sockets and wrenches. the shifter generally comes with instructions, and its pretty straight forward. you do it from inside the car.

unscrew the shift ball, and you've got to use a little force to snap off that piece of the console. be careful because the leather boot is connected to that piece, and unfortunatly is attached by flimsy and easy to break snaps. also, depending on the year, your cigarette lighter is in that console but is connected by some wires that have some slack, so just pull the piece out a little and disconnect the lighter.

good luck and enjoy!

engineman312 09-10-2009 11:12 AM


Originally Posted by Tape (Post 426103)
if you take a stock shifter and flip it over then measure the travel of the ball it will be exactly the same of any "short throw shifter" I have researched all this, I'm not saying it's not worth changing from stock to aftermarket, it should be one of the first mods done to ones mustang.

ppl that research = "i couldn't do it myself but i read about other ppl doing it"

TNell 09-11-2009 09:01 PM

the short shifters shift shorter because the fulcrum is higher than stock. lets say on a stock shifter the ball moves 2 inches and the top of the handle moves 6inches (just makin up the numbers). then use the SAME length handle on a short shifter. the ball will still move the same 2 inches but because the fulcrum is higher the top of the handle might move only 4 (again just makin up numbers but the principle is sound).

Now put a longer handle on the short shifter. the ball will still move 2 inches but the top of the handle will move more than it did with the shorter handle and maybe more than stock even.

If you put a 4 foot handle on a tri-ax or pro5.0 the throw would be quite long.
Conversely, if you just grab the stub of the stock shifter the throw is pretty short.

there are 2 variables in play here. the fulcrum point and the length of the handle.

for any given shifter a longer handle means a longer throw (think about an old school bus). but between different shifters the position of the fulcrum comes into play as well as the length of the handle.

short handle =short throw but more importantly higher fulcrum=shorter throw

but the ball does always move the same as some pointed out. that's a function ot the tranny internals not the shifter.

That Hurst handle WILL shift shorter on a short shifter than it would if you put it on a stock shifter

and i slept at a holiday inn express last night

lonestar stang 10-15-2009 04:44 PM

i was gonna swap out my shifter as well, but wasnt sure what type of transmission was stock for my mustang('99 V6). to be honest, i dont know all that i should about my mustang

spike_africa 10-16-2009 07:44 AM

You have a T45/T5 manual transmission.

jameslf 10-16-2009 12:33 PM


Originally Posted by TNell (Post 428734)
the short shifters shift shorter because the fulcrum is higher than stock. lets say on a stock shifter the ball moves 2 inches and the top of the handle moves 6inches (just makin up the numbers). then use the SAME length handle on a short shifter. the ball will still move the same 2 inches but because the fulcrum is higher the top of the handle might move only 4 (again just makin up numbers but the principle is sound).

Now put a longer handle on the short shifter. the ball will still move 2 inches but the top of the handle will move more than it did with the shorter handle and maybe more than stock even.

If you put a 4 foot handle on a tri-ax or pro5.0 the throw would be quite long.
Conversely, if you just grab the stub of the stock shifter the throw is pretty short.

there are 2 variables in play here. the fulcrum point and the length of the handle.

for any given shifter a longer handle means a longer throw (think about an old school bus). but between different shifters the position of the fulcrum comes into play as well as the length of the handle.

short handle =short throw but more importantly higher fulcrum=shorter throw

but the ball does always move the same as some pointed out. that's a function ot the tranny internals not the shifter.

That Hurst handle WILL shift shorter on a short shifter than it would if you put it on a stock shifter

and i slept at a holiday inn express last night

I'm glad someone finally said it correctly. I didn't want to type all that.
And by the way, the fellow with the '99 V6 does not have a T45. That was only behind the 4.6L. He's got the old T5.

spike_africa 10-16-2009 02:10 PM


Originally Posted by jameslf (Post 434438)
I'm glad someone finally said it correctly. I didn't want to type all that.
And by the way, the fellow with the '99 V6 does not have a T45. That was only behind the 4.6L. He's got the old T5.

You sir are correct. I hit the 4 when I hit 5 and didn't see it. I changed it because they both use the same shifter anyhow. Thanks for correction. :)

Kyanbi 10-16-2009 05:41 PM

I'm just curious, as I'm thinking about a short shifter being one of my next mods, what would the fulcrum be in this point? My brain is pretty mushy after work.

http://www.mgwltd.com/images/mustang_shifter_3650.jpg

Would this fulcrum on this MGW short-throw shifter be the base of the threaded rod in which the shifter handle affixes to or the part where the orange handle affixes to the rest of the shifter?

Bullitt5339 10-16-2009 06:51 PM

I read this entire thread, thinking "What a bunch of idiots"........Until TNell posted, and then a few others posted up. The guy who said there's not difference obviously knows nothing about nothing. TNell is exactly right. By changing the fulcrum height, it effectively changes the length of the shifter throw.

The fulcrum is in the base, where the pivot point is. If dude had ever held both shifters in his hands together, he would never say they are the same except for bushings.

As far as recommendations of the Hurst and the Pro 5.0.............If you recommend the Hurst or Pro 5.0, it's because that's the only aftermarket shifter you've ever used. I've had Mustangs for 20 years, and tried almost every shifter on every transmission, and can't recommend either of those to anyone.

If you want one of the best shifters on the market, there's only 2 in my eyes to ever recommend. The Steeda TriAx, which I had in my GT, and the MGW, which I have in my Bullitt. They both feel different, but are equally good. It all comes down to which one you like better. I would definately recommend that you find someone with each one of them, and row the gears a couple times. At first, I liked the Steeda better, but after getting used to the stiffness of the MGW, whenever I drive with the Steeda, I miss the MGW. But in all honesty, either of those two are leaps and bounds above everything else offered currently.

The worst shifter I've ever laid hands on is the UPR Blue Thunder shifter. Absolutely horrible. 3rd gear is harder to hit than with the factory garbage.

I wouldn't take the MGW out of the Bullitt for any other shifter........period. But if I had a Steeda TriAx in there already, I wouldn't have bought the MGW to begin with. Either are that good.

Bullitt5339 10-16-2009 06:52 PM


Originally Posted by Kyanbi (Post 434487)
I'm just curious, as I'm thinking about a short shifter being one of my next mods, what would the fulcrum be in this point? My brain is pretty mushy after work.

http://www.mgwltd.com/images/mustang_shifter_3650.jpg

Would this fulcrum on this MGW short-throw shifter be the base of the threaded rod in which the shifter handle affixes to or the part where the orange handle affixes to the rest of the shifter?

you can't see the fulcrum in that picture, it's inside the black base, where the pivot point is.

Bullitt5339 10-16-2009 06:56 PM


Originally Posted by Tape (Post 425849)
if thats what you believe then believe it, you cannot change anything but the length of the shifter arm, the shifters stock and aftermarket have the exact same travel, or it wouldn't work, you cannot change the travel in the transmission, only the length of the shifter arm defines it as a shortshifter.

They have to have the same travel inside the transmission, or else it wouldn't shit gears.....:confused:

Now, take measurements from the handle, and tell me the difference between how far the stock handle vs. the aftermarket handle moves. Use the same handle on each shifter just to make sure there's no difference in handle length that would affect throw, and tell me what you come up with.

I already know the answer, as I did it when I bought my first Pro 5.0 years ago. Then you can come back and tell me where the difference is made up at.

Kyanbi 10-16-2009 08:17 PM


Originally Posted by Bullitt5339 (Post 434494)
You can't see the fulcrum in that picture; it's inside the black base, where the pivot point is.

Ah, alright! Just curious... so in case anyone asks me why I decided to get a short shifter I truly know the answer. It's always good to know exactly how something works ;)


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:02 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands