Seat Belt Laws
#1
06-07-2006 | 09:06 AM
Thread Starter
|
V6 Power
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 944
From: Melbourne, FL
Seat Belt Laws
Now, I usually wear my seatbelt, expecually if i am in my own car but i just dont think that it should be against the law to not wear it. If the guy hits me and he doesnt have a seatbelt on, it wont do any harm to me. Nobody gets hurt because someone else didnt wear there seatbelt.
So what do you guys think, should a grown adult be able to choose to wear or not wear a seatbelt? or should the government be able to tell them.
Personally i believe it is these little things that people let go because it isnt a big deal or by saying (who cares i allways wear a seatbelt) that hurts our freedoms and starts letting more and more laws pass that go against what this country stands for.
So what do you guys think, should a grown adult be able to choose to wear or not wear a seatbelt? or should the government be able to tell them.
Personally i believe it is these little things that people let go because it isnt a big deal or by saying (who cares i allways wear a seatbelt) that hurts our freedoms and starts letting more and more laws pass that go against what this country stands for.
#4
06-07-2006 | 10:55 AM
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by mustangV6_04
ya but what if someone hit you and they weren't wearing thier seatbelt and they die who are you gonna sue?
#5
06-07-2006 | 11:01 AM
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 1,805
From: royal palm beach, florida
Originally Posted by zigzagg321
If you were to sue anyone it would have to be the dead persons family in a civil suit...I dont know if you could even do that which is more of a reason to keep seatbelt laws in place and wear yours EVERY time you drive or ride. The bottom line is that it is just stupid not to wear it. period.
Originally Posted by zigzagg321
belt laws help keep insurance rates down for everyone...and it's plain stupid not to wear one.
#6
06-07-2006 | 11:01 AM
Thread Starter
|
V6 Power
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 944
From: Melbourne, FL
Originally Posted by zigzagg321
belt laws help keep insurance rates down for everyone...and it's plain stupid not to wear one.
I am not arguing weather you should or shouldnt. Im arguing that the government shouldnt be able to force anyone.
Its like the government banning fatty foods.
#7
06-07-2006 | 11:02 AM
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 1,805
From: royal palm beach, florida
Originally Posted by Teal_Beast
thats besides the point. There is a diffrence between saying "thats dumb you should do it anyway" and having your government FORCE you to.
I am not arguing weather you should or shouldnt. Im arguing that the government shouldnt be able to force anyone.
Its like the government banning fatty foods.
I am not arguing weather you should or shouldnt. Im arguing that the government shouldnt be able to force anyone.
Its like the government banning fatty foods.
i agree with you... i wear my seat belt every single day but i dont want the government telling me i have to. and pulling me over at random just to make sure im still wearing it.
#8
06-07-2006 | 11:38 AM
jjtgiants
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 4,177
From: Dublin, CA
We elect our goverment officials to protect the health and safety of the citizens of this country, state, county, and city. We all know that seatbelts save lives and I don't think that's what we are arguing, but if government knows seatbelts can save 7 out of 10 people from dying in accidents then it would be neglegent on their part not do anything about it. ( I don't know what the actual statistic is, I was just making a point) Now you can argue that it's your right to die in an accident if you want, but governments job is to try their best to protect people and sometimes protecting them for their own good.....now that is a very fine line and I'm not advocating government should stick there nose in everything, but I think stuff like seatbelts are not a big deal because DRIVING IS NOT A RIGHT, IT'S A PRIVILEGE. That's why the DMV can take peoples licenses away for being a jack azz's and they can't do jack about it! It's also why they can take the license of senior citizens who have eye issues or dementia!
#9
06-07-2006 | 11:53 AM
Thread Starter
|
V6 Power
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 944
From: Melbourne, FL
Originally Posted by jjtgiants
We elect our goverment officials to protect the health and safety of the citizens of this country, state, county, and city. We all know that seatbelts save lives and I don't think that's what we are arguing, but if government knows seatbelts can save 7 out of 10 people from dying in accidents then it would be neglegent on their part not do anything about it. ( I don't know what the actual statistic is, I was just making a point) Now you can argue that it's your right to die in an accident if you want, but governments job is to try their best to protect people and sometimes protecting them for their own good.....now that is a very fine line and I'm not advocating government should stick there nose in everything, but I think stuff like seatbelts are not a big deal because DRIVING IS NOT A RIGHT, IT'S A PRIVILEGE. That's why the DMV can take peoples licenses away for being a jack azz's and they can't do jack about it! It's also why they can take the license of senior citizens who have eye issues or dementia!
#10
06-07-2006 | 11:54 AM
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 1,805
From: royal palm beach, florida
Originally Posted by Teal_Beast
So why is Alchohol and Cigerettes legal? It isnt that it is our choice to die or not, it is our choice to take the risk, just like the risk asccociated with smoking cigerettes or any tobacco product. Or driving at all!
hahaha, alcohol is legal because prohibiton was a failure... produced more crime than it prevented.
#11
06-07-2006 | 12:19 PM
jjtgiants
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 4,177
From: Dublin, CA
Originally Posted by Teal_Beast
So why is Alchohol and Cigerettes legal? It isnt that it is our choice to die or not, it is our choice to take the risk, just like the risk asccociated with smoking cigerettes or any tobacco product. Or driving at all!
the fact is that driving is a privilege so requiring you to wear a seatbelt is not taking away or infringing on your rights, it's basically saying....follow the rules of the privilege and we won't take the privilege away! It's kinda like getting on a ride at disneyland and them saying that you have to put your safety belt on in order to ride the rollercoaster.....ok, you don't want to, then you don't ride it! ha ha ha
#12
06-07-2006 | 12:22 PM
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 1,805
From: royal palm beach, florida
Originally Posted by jjtgiants
the fact is that driving is a privilege so requiring you to wear a seatbelt is not taking away or infringing on your rights, it's basically saying....follow the rules of the privilege and we won't take the privilege away! It's kinda like getting on a ride at disneyland and them saying that you have to put your safety belt on in order to ride the rollercoaster.....ok, you don't want to, then you don't ride it! ha ha ha
i understand everything you're saying but what they're doing down here is kinda like stopping that rollercoaster ride at random just to check and make sure your hands are still inside the car... kinda takes the fun out of riding. they can stop us pretty much at random just to make sure our belts are on.
#13
06-07-2006 | 12:39 PM
jjtgiants
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 4,177
From: Dublin, CA
Originally Posted by floppy
i understand everything you're saying but what they're doing down here is kinda like stopping that rollercoaster ride at random just to check and make sure your hands are still inside the car... kinda takes the fun out of riding. they can stop us pretty much at random just to make sure our belts are on.
#14
06-07-2006 | 12:43 PM
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 1,805
From: royal palm beach, florida
Originally Posted by jjtgiants
I understand your concern now.....We went through the same thing in Cali, but now I don't think they can radomly pull people over....they can pull you over if they see you don't have your seatbelt on and give you a ticket. Is the seatbelt law new to your state? I think when it was new in Cali they did the random thing and then eased up on that and now the Highway Patrol have signs they say "click it or ticket".
yeah we have that click it or ticket thing too, and we have commercials and billboards for it everywhere. they changed the laws years ago so that they could pull you over if they saw that you werent wearing your seat belt. but just recently they changed it so that you could be pulled over just on suspicion that you may not be wearing it. you dont have to do anything wrong and they can pull you over "just to check". i remember a couple years ago they would have road blocks and they would check every single person driving down the road to make sure they had their seat belts on.
I wear my seat belt, i shouldnt have to be pulled over so they can "check" on me.
#15
06-07-2006 | 12:56 PM
jjtgiants
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 4,177
From: Dublin, CA
oh well the random checks are not a good thing at all.... maybe before long somoene will challenge the law in court and hopefully it will be reversed. But then again they can do DUI check points so it might be ok for them to do....either way it stinks!
#16
06-07-2006 | 02:31 PM
Guest
Posts: n/a
Hell yeah everyone SHOULD have to wear thier seatbelt.The idea that not wearing your seatbelt on endangers the person without the belt is bullcrap.
You guys ever seen REAL TV? or MOST AMAZING VIDEO's? or WILD POLICE CHASES?
They got idiots every now and then that are hauling *** and lose control, they get ejected from thier car and dammit, they CAN land on yer car or cause even a bigger wreck.
Imagine driving to the movies with your girlfriend or wife, some idiot in oncoming traffic is digging for a CD and doesent have his seatbelt on. Pulls into your lane, WHAM, head on collision and that dirtbag gets turned into a meat missle, flys through his windshield, your windshield, and impales/kills your wife/girlfriend
Thats my take on it. Wear your damn seatbelt, keep youself safe, keep insurance costs down, and dont be a meat missle.
#18
06-07-2006 | 05:17 PM
Guest
Posts: n/a
I just dont think its wrong for the gov't to make things into law that really do protect us and are also not a PITA to follow. I hate the big brother thing..but this is different IMO. If I were the Prez I would say STFU AND PUT ON YOUR F'ING SEATBELT YOU IDIOTS. And, I do absolutely think people who choose not to wear their seatbelts are idiots, morons, dumbasses etc. Just put the fuggin thing on and STFU! I have had several friend killed in car accidents due to them not wearing their seatbelts. JUST STUPID! Makes me pissed just thinking about it...what a dumb way to die.
#19
06-07-2006 | 07:23 PM
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,237
its the law here but you cant get pulled over for it. Now if you get pulled over for something else, that can be included with the ticket. Some cops are dicks about it, some not. Ive gotten a seatbelt ticket and havent another time. In Illinois you can be pulled over for it and they are pretty strict.
#23
06-07-2006 | 08:13 PM
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by Lances03GT
Oh yea me too.I just don't see how not wearing your seatbelt should be against the law.It should just be a personal choice.
#24
06-07-2006 | 08:26 PM
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by Lances03GT
The only reason it's even a law is for more revenue in my opinion.Alot of you that say wear them are probally against helmet laws too.
the way i see it, if yer on a bike and you get into a wreck yer definatly gonna be a meat missle. The helmet just means yer gonna live on life support and die slower. <laugh>
I just dont want some retard who diddnt wanna wear his seatbelt to get thrown out and go rocketing across traffic and slamming into my car.
Could you imagine seatbelt law for bikes? lol... that be freakin insane
Just curious, has anyone else here been in a car on the passenger side, and got broadsided on the passenger side with the driver not wearing a seatbelt? Oh yeah. 170lbs worth of human slamming into you at 40mph is not a good thing. cause that is what happens.....
Helmet's are designed to keep the rider safe, that is it. Seatbelts protect everyone who is in the car.
#27
06-08-2006 | 05:31 PM
Super Moderator
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 9,684
From: Carthage, Missouri
Originally Posted by jjtgiants
Anyone who thinks seatbelts don't save lives should be checked into a mental hospital!
We have enough freedom robbing laws in this country!!
#28
06-08-2006 | 05:40 PM
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by Lances03GT
We have enough freedom robbing laws in this country!!
they are about to ban smoking in denver,... why not ban fast food? its worse than smoking. and ban achohol, cause it is addicting. someday we will all be like the people in that movie "The Island" just not with the whole clone and certain death thing. all of our lives will be dictated and controlled.
america is so happy to **** away its freedoms it is sickening. lol
soilent green is people.
#29
06-08-2006 | 05:50 PM
jjtgiants
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 4,177
From: Dublin, CA
I hear what your saying, but there are a difference between your constitutional rights (freedoms) and privileges and I was arguing that driving is a privilege and not a right so it has nothing to do with your freedoms. Like I said earlier if people don't want to follow the rules associated with the privilege then they don't get that privilege.......it's just like being told to wear your seatbelt on a roller coaster....you don't want to, then you don't ride...it's simple. The seatbelt law is to help save lives and if people don't want to follow it then they can pay the tickets or lose the privilege.
Now, what I don't like is the police setting up checkpoints or randomly pulling people over to check if they are wearing their seatbelt....that's leads to a whole different can of worms.
We also have a motorcycle helmet law here in Cali and when the State was passing the law people faught it like crazy, but it's worked out good. You never really hear people bitch about it, they just follow the law....or they don't ride their motorcycle.
Now, what I don't like is the police setting up checkpoints or randomly pulling people over to check if they are wearing their seatbelt....that's leads to a whole different can of worms.
We also have a motorcycle helmet law here in Cali and when the State was passing the law people faught it like crazy, but it's worked out good. You never really hear people bitch about it, they just follow the law....or they don't ride their motorcycle.
#30
06-08-2006 | 05:52 PM
Super Moderator
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 9,684
From: Carthage, Missouri
Originally Posted by Jack The Ripper
I gotta admit, you have a point there.
they are about to ban smoking in denver,... why not ban fast food? its worse than smoking. and ban achohol, cause it is addicting. someday we will all be like the people in that movie "The Island" just not with the whole clone and certain death thing. all of our lives will be dictated and controlled.
america is so happy to **** away its freedoms it is sickening. lol
soilent green is people.
they are about to ban smoking in denver,... why not ban fast food? its worse than smoking. and ban achohol, cause it is addicting. someday we will all be like the people in that movie "The Island" just not with the whole clone and certain death thing. all of our lives will be dictated and controlled.
america is so happy to **** away its freedoms it is sickening. lol
soilent green is people.