Ford Racing Bullitt Pedals (Manual)
 

Is everyone else's accelerator pedal plastic where rubber is supposed to be?

its suppose to be plastic there a pin that hooks into the back of it.

im talking about the side facing the driver...

you mean the black ones? If so, let me go check.....

Yeah they are, so are the dead pedal ones. the only rubber feeling ones are on the break pedal on mine.